McDonald’s to Open on Christmas Day: Holiday Pay, Overtime, and Unions

McDonald’s is pushing its franchise owners to open their stores on Christmas, and the fast-food chain won’t be paying workers holiday overtime at company-owned stores. Traditionally, many employers that require employees to work on major holidays extend some bonuses or an increased pay rate for the day; does that mean McDonald’s and other stores have any requirement to pay holiday overtime?

Holiday Pay Not Required and Overtime Rules Still Apply

A common myth among many business owners is that they are required to provide days off for holiday to their employees and if they do require them to work, they have to be prepared to pay them extra. Even in the employee-friendly state of California there is no requirement to provide employees with paid holidays nor a “holiday pay.” The law allows employers to set their own holidays, if any. They must follow their policy, but there are some employers that do not provide for any holidays at all.

As a clarification, overtime rules still apply, i.e. if the non-exempt employee who works more than eight hours in one day or more than forty in one work week is entitled to overtime pay.

Employees May Face Repercussions for Noncompliance

santa mcdonalds

At-will employees may be terminated or demoted for any legal reason. Employees generally have no given right not to work on a holiday unless it’s for religious reasons–even so, this issue gets complicated depending on the number of employees and whether the employer may make reasonable accommodation.

Opening on Christmas, A New Trend?

Last Thanksgiving, Walmart received a lot of press for opening early on Thanksgiving day, even though it was late in the day. There is probably not much difference between opening at 8 PM and 12 A.M. that same evening as did many other retailers. McDonald’s is also not the only fast food restaurant to stay open with some franchises like Jack In-the-Box doing it for years.

Some argue that these moves to open on holidays stems from the struggling economy and recession. It is not clear whether it is just the economy that is contributing to these types of decisions, but rather the change in culture or stigma of remaining open on such a holiday. There was a time when selling gas on Sunday was taboo.

A Fight for Unions

These kinds of moves among big box stores and fast food conglomerates has further drawn the attention of various trade unions. McDonald’s and Walmart obviously do not have union employees, but there is definitely a push to change that.  A business model which relies upon minimum wage workers may help convince employees who desire unionization to be scared off with the argument that the company would be unable to afford it and downsize accordingly.

Federal and state law guarantee the right to form unions. Nothing is automatic and there is a process, but from an employer perspective, unions due pose a significant threat to its bottom line. There are many legal ways that businesses can do to prevent unionization. Walmart is said to even have a hotline for its managers for tips on remaining union free in the event they hear of union organization among its workers.


Ready to speak with an attorney? Contact Form below.

Subscribe to Business Legal Updates

Join thousands of other business owners and receive up-to-date business legal updates straight into your electronic mailbox.

  • Why You Shouldn’t Use Homeless People to Fill Job Vacancies [e132]

    December 19, 2014

    The guys end the week by recapping the story on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and a local non-profit that paid homeless people with food and shelter to work concessions at games.  Then they answer, “How risky is it to discuss my company’s IP with job applicants?” Transcript: NASIR: All right, welcome to our podcast where we cover...
    Read More

  • Disrupting Employee Health Insurance

    December 18, 2014

    A recent New York Times rumination about running a small business, employee health insurance and the apparent inevitability of higher cost and compromised benefits wound around to this somewhat plaintive reflection: Yet, I have a feeling that somewhere there has to be better thinking and insight about the health insurance mess. That is where a lot of...
    Read More

  • The Perils of Signing Up For Free Trials [e131]

    December 17, 2014

    Nasir and Matt discuss how signing up for free trials can backfire for consumers and businesses.  They also answer the question, “I used to occupy the space next door but I needed less space, so after I left that area the landlord rented out that extra space to someone who offers the same type of...
    Read More

  • Advertising & Marketing: A Legal Guide for Small Business

    December 16, 2014

    Staying compliant with advertising and marketing is simple if you focus on just being truthful and clear with your customers. The rest is just understanding some subtleties on how to navigate the common legal traps in marketing. Look to the FTC “Protecting America’s consumers for 100 years,” the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) is responsible for eliminating and...
    Read More

  • Complaining About a Restaurant Bill Backfires Against Attorney [e130]

    December 15, 2014

    The guys start the week by detailing the story of a Harvard professor who fought with a restaurant over a $4 discrepancy in his bill.  They then answer, “At what point can I make my employees clock out but take care of non work activities at the office?” Transcript: NASIR: Welcome to the our podcast...
    Read More

  • SEC Compliance Issues for International Crowdfunding Site [e129]

    December 12, 2014

    The guys end the week by talking about an international crowdfunding site getting censured by the SEC.  They also answer, “I live in California but my LLC is setup in another state. At what point am I doing business in California?” Transcript: NASIR: All right, welcome to our podcast where we cover business in the...
    Read More

  • When the Boss Sells the Company

    December 11, 2014

    I once worked for a company that had been rumored, maybe, at some distant time in the future, possibly, but not certainly, perhaps in connection with a potential sale or not, to be tentatively considering relocating to another very fine state, which everyone would certainly love. Then one Monday morning, we were told to stop...
    Read More

  • When a Popular Magazine Gets Accused of Trademark Infringement [e128]

    December 10, 2014

    The guys discuss the fallout from a local San Diego blogger who accused San Diego Magazine of stealing her business name.  They then answer the question, “I’m a sole proprietor. What is some good tax advice to reduce my year end profit?”   Transcript: NASIR: All right, welcome to our podcast where we cover business in...
    Read More

  • The $41 Billion Company Uber is a Horrible Role Model for Business

    December 09, 2014

    You can’t argue with success! I can. Uber is a five-year old company now valued more than 72 percent of any Fortune 500 company. I actually love the concept of Uber: it is disruptive, filling a need, an uber startup, and Uber’s latest round of funding raising $1.2 billion at a $41 billion valuation is a confirmation of...
    Read More

  • Blatant Sexual Harassment at Zillow (Alleged) and Legalities of Weight Loss Contests [e127]

    December 08, 2014

    Nasir and Matt start the week by discussing the blatant forms of sexual harassment alleged at Zillow.  They also answer “My office is planning on doing a weight loss competition at the beginning of the year. Is this legal?” Transcript: NASIR: All right, welcome to our podcast where we cover business in the news and...
    Read More

Misclassifying Your Workforce

This free guide shows you how to avoid the worst & most common mistake in your business.

Get Free Download Now