McDonald’s to Open on Christmas Day: Holiday Pay, Overtime, and Unions

McDonald’s is pushing its franchise owners to open their stores on Christmas, and the fast-food chain won’t be paying workers holiday overtime at company-owned stores. Traditionally, many employers that require employees to work on major holidays extend some bonuses or an increased pay rate for the day; does that mean McDonald’s and other stores have any requirement to pay holiday overtime?

Holiday Pay Not Required and Overtime Rules Still Apply

A common myth among many business owners is that they are required to provide days off for holiday to their employees and if they do require them to work, they have to be prepared to pay them extra. Even in the employee-friendly state of California there is no requirement to provide employees with paid holidays nor a “holiday pay.” The law allows employers to set their own holidays, if any. They must follow their policy, but there are some employers that do not provide for any holidays at all.

As a clarification, overtime rules still apply, i.e. if the non-exempt employee who works more than eight hours in one day or more than forty in one work week is entitled to overtime pay.

Employees May Face Repercussions for Noncompliance

santa mcdonalds

At-will employees may be terminated or demoted for any legal reason. Employees generally have no given right not to work on a holiday unless it’s for religious reasons–even so, this issue gets complicated depending on the number of employees and whether the employer may make reasonable accommodation.

Opening on Christmas, A New Trend?

Last Thanksgiving, Walmart received a lot of press for opening early on Thanksgiving day, even though it was late in the day. There is probably not much difference between opening at 8 PM and 12 A.M. that same evening as did many other retailers. McDonald’s is also not the only fast food restaurant to stay open with some franchises like Jack In-the-Box doing it for years.

Some argue that these moves to open on holidays stems from the struggling economy and recession. It is not clear whether it is just the economy that is contributing to these types of decisions, but rather the change in culture or stigma of remaining open on such a holiday. There was a time when selling gas on Sunday was taboo.

A Fight for Unions

These kinds of moves among big box stores and fast food conglomerates has further drawn the attention of various trade unions. McDonald’s and Walmart obviously do not have union employees, but there is definitely a push to change that.  A business model which relies upon minimum wage workers may help convince employees who desire unionization to be scared off with the argument that the company would be unable to afford it and downsize accordingly.

Federal and state law guarantee the right to form unions. Nothing is automatic and there is a process, but from an employer perspective, unions due pose a significant threat to its bottom line. There are many legal ways that businesses can do to prevent unionization. Walmart is said to even have a hotline for its managers for tips on remaining union free in the event they hear of union organization among its workers.


Ready to speak with an attorney? Contact Form below.

Misclassifying Your Workforce

This free guide shows you how to avoid the worst & most common mistake in your business.

Get Free Download Now

  • Starbucks Suffers from a Holiday Promotion Gone Awry [e121]

    November 21, 2014

    Nasir and Matt close out the week by talking about the Starbucks’ promotion that resulted in untended buy one get one free offers.   The guys then answer, “Can I have one of my employees also be a contractor for special events?” Here is the image of the coupon and the tweet exchange with Starbucks from @daveraleigh. […]

    Read More
  • Should I Organize My Business as a Professional Corporation?

    November 20, 2014

    The professional corporation, or PC, is a form of business organization available under various state laws to narrow list of licensed professionals, including doctors, dentists, chiropractors and acupuncturists. Decisions about business form tend to boil down to weighing the advantages and disadvantages of any particular structure with respect to personal liability and tax matters, but […]

    Read More
  • Why the USPS Data Breach was Significantly Different [e120]

    November 19, 2014

    The guys discuss the recent data breach at the US Postal Service that led to confidential employee information being compromised.  They also answer the question, “What do I need to do to my guest room to make it a writeoff for my business?”

    Read More
  • How to Avoid Legal Liability for Your User’s Content

    November 18, 2014

    A common risk of user-submitted content is that it may infringe on the copyright or trademark of another.  Even with a disclaimer of liability and indemnification from users (discussed below), web site operators may be left vulnerable to claims for Contributory Infringement. Contributory Infringement To be held liable for contributory infringement for the acts of  users, web site […]

    Read More
  • How to Sell a Trademark and Avoiding Infringement [e119]

    November 17, 2014

    Nasir and Matt start the week by discussing Ohio State University suing a t-shirt company for trademark infringement and unfair competition after t-shirts were sold with school names, logos, and slogans.  They then answer, “Many years ago we bought up a bunch of trademarks for potential names for new product lines. Someone approached us to […]

    Read More
  • Are Restaurants Legally Allowed to Play Music and TV? [e118]

    November 14, 2014

    The guys end the week by discussing a recent lawsuit in New York involving restaurants being sued by the music industry for playing music. They answer the question, “One of our former employees filed a frivulous lawsuit against us. Our attorney is reluctant to countersue for malicious prosecution so should I just forget about it?”

    Read More
  • Net Neutrality and Small Business

    November 13, 2014

    Why is everybody yelling about net neutrality, and why now? Actually, it’s a very big deal for small businesses with an online presence, and the Federal Communications Commission may have added fuel to the fire by sending confusing messages about its regulatory intentions. In the political world, it seems to put the President at odds […]

    Read More
  • How Small Businesses Handle Security Breaches [e117]

    November 12, 2014

    The guys talk about the email Nasir received about informing customers of a security breach.  They then answer the question, “Every quarter we have to take care of some corporate stuff and many of my employees are required to work on the weekend. Some of the employees have voiced complaints but can I legally […]

    Read More
  • Ammo To Go’s Remarkable Response to Data Breach

    November 11, 2014

    Earlier this month,, an online ammunition retailer, sent out an e-mail to  customers disclosing the theft of consumer information including e-mail addresses and passwords. The e-mail provided a link to a password reset page and offered assistance to stop possible SPAM from anyone who might have purchased the list. It’s a remarkably pro-active response […]

    Read More
  • Executive Leaves Lyft for Uber and a Lawsuit Ensues [e116]

    November 10, 2014

    Nasir and Matt talk about the COO who left Lyft for Uber and is now being accused of breaching confidentiality agreements and soliciting employees.  They then answer, “What is some good advice to avoid copyright infringement issues?”

    Read More