McDonald’s to Open on Christmas Day: Holiday Pay, Overtime, and Unions

McDonald’s is pushing its franchise owners to open their stores on Christmas, and the fast-food chain won’t be paying workers holiday overtime at company-owned stores. Traditionally, many employers that require employees to work on major holidays extend some bonuses or an increased pay rate for the day; does that mean McDonald’s and other stores have any requirement to pay holiday overtime?

Holiday Pay Not Required and Overtime Rules Still Apply

A common myth among many business owners is that they are required to provide days off for holiday to their employees and if they do require them to work, they have to be prepared to pay them extra. Even in the employee-friendly state of California there is no requirement to provide employees with paid holidays nor a “holiday pay.” The law allows employers to set their own holidays, if any. They must follow their policy, but there are some employers that do not provide for any holidays at all.

As a clarification, overtime rules still apply, i.e. if the non-exempt employee who works more than eight hours in one day or more than forty in one work week is entitled to overtime pay.

Employees May Face Repercussions for Noncompliance

santa mcdonalds

At-will employees may be terminated or demoted for any legal reason. Employees generally have no given right not to work on a holiday unless it’s for religious reasons–even so, this issue gets complicated depending on the number of employees and whether the employer may make reasonable accommodation.

Opening on Christmas, A New Trend?

Last Thanksgiving, Walmart received a lot of press for opening early on Thanksgiving day, even though it was late in the day. There is probably not much difference between opening at 8 PM and 12 A.M. that same evening as did many other retailers. McDonald’s is also not the only fast food restaurant to stay open with some franchises like Jack In-the-Box doing it for years.

Some argue that these moves to open on holidays stems from the struggling economy and recession. It is not clear whether it is just the economy that is contributing to these types of decisions, but rather the change in culture or stigma of remaining open on such a holiday. There was a time when selling gas on Sunday was taboo.

A Fight for Unions

These kinds of moves among big box stores and fast food conglomerates has further drawn the attention of various trade unions. McDonald’s and Walmart obviously do not have union employees, but there is definitely a push to change that.  A business model which relies upon minimum wage workers may help convince employees who desire unionization to be scared off with the argument that the company would be unable to afford it and downsize accordingly.

Federal and state law guarantee the right to form unions. Nothing is automatic and there is a process, but from an employer perspective, unions due pose a significant threat to its bottom line. There are many legal ways that businesses can do to prevent unionization. Walmart is said to even have a hotline for its managers for tips on remaining union free in the event they hear of union organization among its workers.


Ready to speak with an attorney? Contact Form below.

  • Will Fast Food Companies Finally Be Liable for Unfair Labor Practices? [e107]

    October 20, 2014

    Nasir and Matt talk about the possibility of a law being changed to make franchisors liable for unfair labor practices.  They also answer, “I am the sole managing member of a Delaware based LLC. Recently, I was engaged by a company to do consulting work. They requested that I fill out a Federal Form W-9. […]

    Read More
  • How to Get Fired When Complaining to Your TV Provider [e106]

    October 17, 2014

    Nasir and Matt end the week by discussing the accountant who got fired from his job after a dispute he had with Comcast.  They then answer the question, “We just brought on our first set of employees. How should we structure their pay to make them happy now and not have it backfire long-term?”

    Read More
  • Bring Your Own Device – Good Idea?

    October 16, 2014

    Many employers now either expect or permit employees to use their own electronic devices – smartphones, tablets and laptops – for work.  For company purposes, those devices need access to the company network and vice versa.  It seems very much a part of an open information culture and the trend toward blending professional and personal lives. […]

    Read More
  • Women-Owned Businesses and Minimum Wage with Anita Ron [e105]

    October 15, 2014

    Anita Ron, President of BriteWorks, joins the show to talk about how her company has been affected by being a certified women-owned business and the the increase in minimum wage.  She also provides her input on the question, “I allow my employees to BYOD for their jobs. What should be my biggest concerns, or should I […]

    Read More
  • Are Women-Only Gyms Discriminatory?

    October 14, 2014

    Why don’t health clubs that restrict their membership to women run afoul of discrimination laws?  Or for that matter, why don’t any clubs that restrict membership by gender violate the law? The answer, in short, is that sometimes they do, but not always. The question involves Title VII of the Civil Rights Act as well […]

    Read More
  • How California Businesses Must Respond to Data Breaches [e104]

    October 13, 2014

    The guys kick off the week by discussing the new requirement for California businesses to provide identity theft solution services after data breaches.  They then answer the question, “We developed some IP for clients and could not decide on who owns the IP. As a result, we decided to jointly own it. Should I be worried […]

    Read More
  • Why Recording People In Your Car May Be Illegal [e103]

    October 10, 2014

    The guys end the week talking about why the valet mode in Corvettes may be illegal in some states.   I want to make a short web series that is similar to a popular TV show. How much should I be worried about copyright infringement?”

    Read More
  • Civil Forfeiture and the Cash Problem

    October 09, 2014

    Halloween is nearly upon us, and if you feel an adolescent need to terrify your lawyer, or your landlord or shut down an airport, try paying in cash. Used twenties in a brown paper lunch bag would be best;  grease stains add a special touch. Actually, don’t try this, unless you crave law enforcement attention. […]

    Read More
  • Navigating the Sales Tax Rules with Mark Faggiano [e102]

    October 08, 2014

    Nasir and Matt welcome Mark Faggiano of TaxJar to discuss how business owners can comply with the various sales tax rules.  They also answer, “I’m looking to incorporate in the next few months. How much should the tax consequences play a factor in my decision making?”

    Read More
  • Google Requires Physical Addresses for App Developers

    October 07, 2014

    On October 1, Google began requiring all developers of paid apps or apps with in-app purchases (IAPs) to post a physical address to appear on the details page, visible to all users of Google Play. Hobbyists and indie developers, who likely have no physical address other than home, were horrified by the privacy risks. Much […]

    Read More
  • Store Known to Discriminate Gets Caught Up in Religious Discrimination [e101]

    October 06, 2014

    Nasir and Matt kick off the next 100 episodes by discussing the religious discrimination lawsuit involving Abercrombie.  They also answer, “The retailer argues in its brief that job applicants should not be allowed “to remain silent and to assume that the employer recognizes the religious motivations behind their fashion decisions.”

    Read More
  • Is God a Football Fan?

    October 02, 2014

    So asks the back cover of Don DeLillo’s beautiful and disturbing 1973 novel, End Zone. In the tenor of the times, this strange, dark story dealt with American dystopia and the threat of nuclear war. Today, even without the threat of nuclear war, football and religion are as entangled as ever. On Monday night, Kansas […]

    Read More
  • Episode 100! – Updates to Previous Podcast Stories

    October 01, 2014

    Nasir and Matt record together for the first time for the 100th episode.  They give some updates on stories discussed in previous episodes of the podcast, including Arian Foster’s failed IPO, the Ryan Seacrest patent dispute with Blackberry, Johnny Manziel’s trademarks, the outcome from the Airbnb squatter, the settlement from the Oakland Raiders cheerleaders, and the podcast patent […]

    Read More
  • Should You Finance the Sale of Your Business?

    September 30, 2014

    Truthfully, most sellers don’t want to take back paper. An all-cash deal often looks like the easiest and cleanest way to get on to the next venture, much preferable to waiting for another 5 to 7 years to collect a portion of the sale price from a buyer who might conceivably default. Along with the […]

    Read More
  • How to Get Revenge on People Who Steal Your Photos [e99]

    September 29, 2014

    Nasir and Matt talk about one woman’s revenge against Huffington Post after she realized it used her photo without giving her credit.  They also answer the question, “We are trying to negotiate a deal on entering into either a joint venture or some profit sharing partnership for our service and wanted to know if we […]

    Read More
  • How Much is My Business Worth?

    September 25, 2014

    You have spent a lot of time building your business, but about three to five years ago you began to think about selling, so you have been taking all the necessary steps to position it for sale. Good for you. Now that it’s time to actually pull the trigger, what kind of price can you […]

    Read More
  • When a Business Must Inform Customers about Competitors [e98]

    September 24, 2014

    Nasir and Matt talk about the recent court decision that requires insurers to inform consumers of the name of a competitor.  They then answer the question, “One of our employees is a backup driver for our food delivery business and we get a discount from our insurance company if our drivers take a defensive driving […]

    Read More
  • Does Macy’s Tell Gimbels? Safelite Revisits Free Speech

    September 23, 2014

    Obviously not, or you wouldn’t have to Google “Gimbles”.  We’ll save you the effort. Gimbles was a New York department store, a block away from Macy’s, and the competition between the two was legendary. You can guess who won, but even today, the question, “Does Macy’s Tell Gimbles?” lives on to mean “Does one business […]

    Read More
  • Must-Reads if You Are Thinking About Buying a Business

    September 18, 2014

    If you are thinking about buying a business, you must have lots of questions. Of course, you should get some help with this process — from your banker, your attorney, your accountant, and possibly a business broker. But no one wants to sail into any of these conversations without a little background first, so here […]

    Read More
  • Product Liability 101 for Small Importers

    September 16, 2014

    Global sourcing has lots of exciting potential. The recent entry of onto the global stage along with others such as the FITA Buy/Sell Exchange, Euro Pages and Global Sources seems to presage a new age of borderless commerce. However, on a bad day, that also looks like caveat emptor on steroids.  Small business owners […]

    Read More